Hightstown, NJ – Purchasing a yearling is similar to buying a lottery ticket to Tim Smith, and the Indiana resident has come up with a winner in Fresh Face Yankee.
Smith bought the trotting filly, a daughter of Crescent Fashion-Swan Yankee, for $5,000 at the 2024 Midwest Classic Mixed Sale. Smith had trained a couple of horses a year for more than three decades but had never driven in a race, and he attended the sale in the hope of getting a horse he could race himself at the Indiana fairs.
“I was 66 and I wanted to do it,” Smith said. “Just a bucket list thing. That was kind of the reason I bought her.”
But Fresh Face Yankee has become much more. As a 2-year-old, she won six times on the fair circuit with Smith in the sulky, including a track-record 1:56.1 performance at the Indiana State Fair to capture the $25,000 Governor’s Cup championship for freshman trotting fillies. All of her victories with Smith at the fairs were by at least 5-1/2 lengths.

Overall last season, Smith drove Fresh Face Yankee in 11 of her 15 races. She made breaks in the five races she lost with Smith but was off the board only once (second-placed-fourth in her career debut) with three runner-up finishes and a third. In her four remaining races, she had an Indiana fair circuit victory at Harrah’s Hoosier Park with driver Trace Tetrick in her third lifetime start, and she ended the year with two wins and a second with driver Jay Cross, also at Hoosier.
Cross brought Fresh Face Yankee to Florida for the winter and when he returned, Smith suggested he train and drive the horse this season. Cross and Fresh Face Yankee have teamed up for 11 top-three finishes, with nine wins, in 13 races. Their most recent triumph, on Oct. 30, came in the $140,000 Grade 3 Crossroads of America at Hoosier Park.
For her career, Fresh Face Yankee has 18 wins in 28 races, $303,585 in earnings, and a best time of 1:52.1.
“It’s just been a dream come true,” Smith said. “The ironic thing is that I had a horse in 2019 called Clever Character, and I paid $5,000 for him. He won five out of six legs of the (Indiana) sire stakes and finished third in the final. To have this happen after I had Clever Character has just been unreal. I attribute it all to the Good Lord nudging me on the right one, I guess. It’s nothing I do. I always look at it as buying a lottery ticket – but there is a lot more work involved.”
Clever Character won more than $200,000 for Smith before being purchased by the Burke Brigade midway through his 3-year-old campaign and capturing the Indiana Sire Stakes title for sophomore male pacers with trainer Ron Burke.
Fresh Face Yankee began her 3-year-old season with eight wins and a second-place finish. Three of the victories came in sweeping the Msnaughtybynature Series to open the campaign and five were in preliminary legs of the Indiana Sire Stakes. She was the 3-5 favorite in the $250,000 ISS Super Final but went off stride early and finished ninth.
After coming back with a third-place finish in the $50,000 Pegasus, she made another miscue in the $45,000 Circle City. A week later, though, with Smith paying a $10,000 supplement fee to enter the race, Fresh Face Yankee won the Crossroads of America to earn a measure of redemption.
“We’ve had a few ups and downs, but for the most part, she’s been unbelievable,” Smith said. “She made a couple bobbles that we really don’t know why; that happens with trotters, I guess. She kind of redeemed herself in the Crossroads of America. She proved that she could do it. I had to supplement her, but I had that much faith in her.
“Like Jay has said, there’s not much that can beat her if she behaves herself. She’s turned out to be quite the filly.”
Smith began to recognize Fresh Face Yankee’s ability when he drove last year.
“Well, it’s like this – she made me look good,” he said with a laugh. “I retired in 2019 from a factory. I’ve always had a horse or two to play with, but I did it part-time. It’s not that I never drove, but I never drove in races as such for money. She was very impressive last year. When she didn’t make a break, there was nobody that could touch her. I’d just get her out of there, go to the top, and we’d just ride.”
On Friday, Fresh Face Yankee will return to action when she meets six rivals in the $45,000 Balmoral Park for 3-year-old trotting fillies at Hoosier. She will leave from post 1 with Cross in the sulky and is the 2-1 second choice on the morning line behind 3-2 favorite For Dayze, who leaves from post 2 with driver John DeLong.
“We had to scratch (Fresh Face Yankee) from her last start because she tied up,” Smith said, referring to the $40,000 Hazel Park on Nov. 6, which was won by For Dayze. “I brought her home and turned her out for a few days and she seems to be good.”
If all goes well, Fresh Face Yankee will race once more this year, on Nov. 27 in the Thanksgiving Classic at Hoosier Park.
“We’ll see what happens, but we’ll stake her some for next year,” Smith said. “I don’t know how much traveling we’ll do, but we’ll see. I’d still like to see her race with some more of the big girls and see what she can do. Jay and (his wife) Pam have done a good job with her. I never imagined she’d be what she is. I keep asking Jay, how fast does he think she can go? And he says that he hopes he never finds out.”
One thing Smith does know is that he plans to keep Fresh Face Yankee despite interest from others.
“There have been people wanting her, but this is what you dream of finding, dream of having,” Smith said. “I’m not in a situation where I’ve got to have money; I’m not rich, but I’m fine, and I’m having a lot of fun. She’s worth more to me than anybody.”
Racing begins at 5:30 p.m. (EST) at Harrah’s Hoosier Park. In addition to the Balmoral Park for 3-year-old trotting fillies, the track is hosting Balmoral Park events for sophomore male trotters as well as sophomore male and female pacers.
For free daily race day programs, visit the Harrah’s Hoosier Park website.